American villa plan rejected on appeal for second time

PUBLISHED: 07:00 12 September 2018 | UPDATED: 12:02 01 October 2018

An artist’s impression of the single-storey villa. Picture: WYG

An artist’s impression of the single-storey villa. Picture: WYG


Plans to build a low-lying American villa in a village have been rejected on appeal again.

A house will not be built at Tyntesfield Springs in Wraxall after more than a decade of negotiations between the applicant, former Wraxall and Failand parish councillor Dr Hugh Pratt and North Somerset Council.

Dr Pratt obtained the rights to the design from the Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation in 2007, his first application was dismissed by North Somerset Council in October 2014 to build a house with off-grid services, including a horizontal vortex hydro-electric turbine, which would provide renewable energy for the home.

The plan went to appeal on August 20, but the planning inspector again dismissed the proposal, citing it as being ‘an inappropriate development in the greenbelt’.

MORE: Unique villa plan to go to appeal after rejection.

A report said: “The proposal is inappropriate development in the greenbelt and harm has been identified to the openness, it does not meet the entirety of the exception to the need to avoid isolated homes in the countryside, and other harm, together with a failure to comply with development plan policies, has been identified.

“The other considerations in favour of the proposal, including the framework paragraphs referred to by the appellants, do not clearly outweigh the potential harm to the greenbelt and any other harm resulting from the proposal, so the very special circumstances required to approve the development have not been found to exist.

“The design of the building is outstanding, and aspects of the plan may be said to be innovative as well as reflecting the highest standards in architecture.

“However, the particulars of this land mean permission should be withheld and the appeal should be dismissed.”

The plan was widely unpopular among villagers and the parish council felt the plans were in ‘stark contrast’ to nearby homes.

Dr Pratt told the Times: “It is a shame since we wish to share our proposed home with free visits by architectural students from universities who study Frank Lloyd Wright as part of their course work, they can only visit his designs by going to America or Japan.”

Other News Stories


Portishead pool is gearing up to celebrate 10 years since it was saved from closure thanks to the hard work of supporters.

Read more

With Christmas little more than six weeks away, some lovely gifts were on sale at the weekend to help shoppers seeking a bargain.

Read more
Yesterday, 16:00

The government is set to invest more than £1million to improve pothole problems in North Somerset.

Read more
Yesterday, 14:00

A rescue centre in Portbury is desperately appealing for foster carers so it can help more abandoned cats in the area.

Read more
Yesterday, 12:28

Portishead Town Council is to ‘demand’ answers on what is happening to money earmarked for the area – following complaints from taxpayers.

Read more
Yesterday, 11:10

A Weston-super-Mare family raised hundreds of pounds for a charity which provides support for their son.

Read more
Yesterday, 10:00

Four police officers from Nailsea are spending a week at a rescue centre for vulnerable girls in Kenya.

Read more
Yesterday, 07:49

Environmental campaigners will be busy helping to tidy up the coastal areas around Portishead at the weekend.

Read more
Yesterday, 06:54

‘Antisocial’ drivers have been caught reaching speeds of more than 70mph in Nailsea town centre.

Read more
Thu, 17:00

The NHS will enhance its services in the South West as it gears-up for the most ‘challenging’ winter in years.

Read more

Most Read News

Read Online

Read the North Somerset Times e-edition E-edition

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 10°C

min temp: 4°C

Useful Links

Reader Travel

Clevedon Tide report

Family Notices 24

Newsletter Sign Up

North Somerset Times twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Show Job Lists

Find planning applications